Far-Fetched Faulkner

Above: New Yorker book critic Clifton Fadiman (right) characterized William Faulkner's "Absalom, Absalom!" as a "penny dreadful tricked up in fancy language." Fadiman was not alone among contemporary mainstream critics in his assessment, although today the novel is considered a masterwork of Southern Gothic literature. (Wikipedia/J.R. Cofield Collection, University of Mississippi Library)

With its non-linear timeline, winding prose, and multiple unreliable narrators, William Faulkner’s Absalom, Absalom! left many critics wondering what to make of the author’s ninth novel, including The New Yorker’s Clifton Fadiman, who had a near-visceral response to Faulkner’s “shuddery inventions.”

October 31, 1936 cover by Perry Barlow.

Although today the novel is widely considered a literary masterpiece, in 1936 Fadiman saw the dense, labyrinthine style of Absalom, Absalom! as nothing more than an empty facade for a melodramatic plot and characters resembling a “mince-pie nightmare.”

The novel explored the rise and fall of Thomas Sutpen, a poor man who ruthlessly carves out a plantation empire in 1830s Mississippi. Told entirely in flashbacks consisting of fragmented memories and differing perspectives, the novel is psychologically bleak and violent, with nearly every major character meeting a tragic end. Following are excerpts from Fadiman’s review:

OXFORD MAN…Above, William Faulkner at his 1844 Greek Revival home, Rowan Oak, which he purchased in Oxford, Mississippi in 1930; below, at work in his study. The mid-1930s were a difficult time for Faulkner. His writing was often interrupted by trips to Hollywood, where he sought additional income writing screenplays (Faulkner was constantly in debt), and in 1935 his brother Dean was killed in a plane crash. Consequently this period included a number of heavy drinking benders. (genteelandbard.com/life.com)

Faulkner had some history with The New Yorker: A Nov. 21, 1931 “Talk of the Town” entry titled “Oxford Man” featured a thirty-four-year-old Faulkner living in a Tudor City apartment, working on his novel Light in August. “Talk” noted his service in the Canadian air force, which he joined in 1915 (he broke both legs in a crash) and that he “sometimes flies a rather wobbly plane owned by a friend in Oxford.” As for his writing style, “Talk” offered this quote from Faulkner: “Ah write when the spirit moves me, and the spirit moves me every day.” The piece also noted that “Only a few of the townspeople know he writes at all; most of them think he’s lazy.”

Here’s a second excerpt from Fadiman’s Oct. 31, 1936 review, in which the critic concludes that Faulkner “is a clever hand at fitting up a literary asylum for the feeble-minded.”

FLYBOY…A 1931 “Talk of the Town” profile, attributed to and  noted Faulkner’s writing habits, his ties to his hometown, and his time in the Canadian Air Force. (espresso.pt)

 * * *

Chattering Mysteries

Those are the words E.B. White used to describe aisles of calculators, addressographs, and electric tabulation machines being operated by women clad “in purest white satin” at a business show on Eighth Avenue.

AN ILLUSION OF THE SENSES was achieved by scores of machines clacking away at a Manhattan business show, according to E.B. White. At left is an Addressograph machine, circa 1930s, and at right, a census worker using an IBM Type 1 mechanical key punch, 1940. (americanbusinesshistory.org/officemuseum.com)

 * * *

At the Movies

Get the Extra-large Popcorn

They say movies are getting longer these days, but the Thirties had its share of lengthy screen epics, including a nearly five-hour running time for the 1934 French adaptation of the Victor Hugo novel Les Misérables. Initially released as three films premiering over three consecutive weeks, the full, unedited film ran a total of 281 minutes. Apparently the 1936 American release, reviewed here by John Mosher, ran for just under three hours, which Mosher called “a crime against nature.” He did, however, pronounce it “a fine film.” He also reviewed a German musical comedy, Amphitryon, and some uninspiring “plain American” films.

GOING HUGE FOR HUGO…Clockwise, from top left: Florelle as Fantine in Les Misérables; blockade scene from the film; Harry Baur as Jean Valjean; French movie poster, 1934. (imdb.com)

Mosher grew weary of reading the subtitles in the German film Amphitryon, a surprising satirical musical that somehow got made even after the Nazis took over the reigns of the Ufa-Atelier studio; however, the coming year would see a further tightening of domestic repression (including film) under Reich leadership.

SOME LAST LAUGHS…Willy Fritsch and Käthe Gold in the 1935 German musical comedy Amphitryon. The movie was filmed in German and French, which is probably why Mosher thought it was a French production. (en.kinorium.com)

The “plain American” films reviewed by Mosher included a mystery, a revue, and a musical featuring opera singer Marion Talley, who years earlier had received some rough treatment from The New Yorker.

STANDARD FARE…Clockwise, from top left: The Charge of the Light Brigade starred Olivia de Havilland and Errol Flynn; Jean Arthur and Joel McCrea in Adventure in Manhattan; Bob Burns and Martha Raye in The Big Broadcast of 1937; Marion Talley and Michael Bartlett in Follow Your Heart; Victor McLaglen and Binnie Barnes in The Magnificent Brute. (britannica.com/theblondeatthefilm.com/imdb.com/tubitv.com/ebay.com)

 * * *

Polymath Porter

The multi-talented composer/songwriter Cole Porter was the latest celebrity to receive a mini bio in the opening pages…illustration by Abe Birnbaum…

…and on the subject of theater, Al Frueh offered his impression of the Talullah Bankhead vehicle, Reflected Glory...

 * * *

From Our Advertisers

Various retailers were gearing up for the coronation of England’s King Edward VIII, and the folks at Yardley’s were busy packaging their lavender-scented soaps and perfumes for royalty-starved Americans, “safeguarded in original royal wrappings”…this “Edwardian” campaign would be scrapped just weeks later when Edward would abdicate the throne (on Dec. 10) and run off with American Wallis Simpson…

…the makers of Beech-Nut chewing gum made a splash with this full-page ad touting their traveling “Smallest Show on Earth”…

…Canadian Club continued its world tour with a stop in Kuala Lumpur…

…No-Mal ran another back-of-the-book ad promoting its scientific “pick-up”…the chief ingredient, according to this spot, was dextrose (even safe for infants!), but it doubtless also contained caffeine and Lord knows what else…

…no extra stimulation needed for our cartoon section, beginning with Mary Petty…

…there were a couple of Halloween-themed spots by Susan Willard Flint…

…and Charles Addams...

 

…a sampling of other spot drawings…Victor de Pauw, Doris Spiegel, and John Groth…

…Alain gave us the true meaning of “table tennis”…

…George Price anticipated a long winter…

…Gardner Rea showed us an Englishman who found Manhattan life a bit too invigorating…

…Alan Dunn posed a question regarding authorship…

…Peter Arno might be referring to something akin to The Great Stork Derby here…

…one of Helen Hokinson’s “girls” sought to stay “off the record”…

…and Hokinson again, casting a vote in the 1936 General Election…

…Whitney Darrow Jr was also thinking about elections, and a clean shave…

…and we close with James Thurber, and an inquiring reporter…

Next Time: The Instant Home…

The So-So Soprano

Although its founding editor, Harold Ross, was raised in the rude surroundings of a Colorado mining town and often displayed the manners of a backwoodsman, the New Yorker nevertheless looked down its sophisticated nose at most anything west of the Hudson, and the middle west was reserved for particular ridicule in its homespun piety and small city boosterism.

April 20, 1929 cover by Adolph K. Kronengold.

Enter one Marion Talley, a child prodigy from the tiny town of Nevada, Missouri. After appearing in a lead role at age 15 for the Kansas City Grand Opera, excited civic leaders raised enough money to send Talley to New York to study voice. Four years later (February 1926) she made her Metropolitan Opera debut as Gilda in Rigoletto — at that time the youngest prima donna to appear on the Met stage. A delegation of Kansas City’s two hundred leading citizens (including the mayor) travelled to New York via special train to attend the performance. Adding to the spectacle, a noisy telegraph machine was set up backstage so Talley’s father could send dispatches back home during the performance. Writing in his “A Reporter at Large” column for the New Yorker’s Feb. 27, 1926 issue, Morris Markey scoffed at the hype and Babbitry on display:

THE BIG TIME…at right, with co-star Michael Bartlett in her only movie, Follow Your Heart (1936); left, promoting Ry-Krisp crackers, sponsor of her NBC radio show, 1937. (imdb.com/mnopedia.org)

The New Yorker (via E.B. White in “Notes & Comment”) caught up with Talley more than three years later in the April 20, 1929 issue, her short career seemingly over, her voice perhaps destined for nothing more than “hog-calling”…

When Talley’s Met contract was not renewed for the 1929 season, she announced her plans to retire to a wheat farm in Kansas (hence the hog calling reference). She did, however, try to revive her career on concert tours and then on her own NBC Radio program (1936-1938), sponsored by Ry-Krisp. She made one film, the 1936 musical Follow Your Heart, but after its tepid reception the 30-year-old Talley decided to retire from show business.

ONE MORE TRY…Testimonial ads promoting weight reduction usually signal the end of a career, and for Marion Talley her Ry-Krisp diet endorsement was no exception. (imdb)

Talley married twice — to pianist Michael Rauchelsen (1932–1934) and to music critic Adolph Eckstein (1935–1942), the latter with whom she had a daughter, Susan. Talley died in 1983 in Beverly Hills, California.

*  *  *

Dark Clouds on the Horizon

The April 20, 1929 “Talk of the Town” made passing mention of a man who would be instrumental in the stock market crash later that year—National City Bank President Charles E. Mitchell:

The “Talk” item references a $25 million advance Mitchell offered to stock market traders who were getting the yips in an overheated market. This happened after a “mini crash” on March 25, 1929, when the Federal Reserve told its banks to withhold all loans to finance securities. Mitchell’s announcement apparently reassured the public enough to stop the panic, but in reality it only delayed the inevitable—a major market crash brought on in large part by the over-selling of securities by Mitchell’s bank.

RUNAWAY BULL…Charles E. Mitchell’s reckless overselling of securities played a large role in the October 1929 stock market crash. Arrested and indicted for tax evasion in 1933, Mitchell would be acquitted of criminal charges but would end up paying a million dollars to the U.S. government in a civil settlement. At right, Walker’s stately townhouse on Fifth Avenue, now home to the French consulate. (geni.com/daytonian in manhattan)

The “Talk” item continued with this observation on the Panic of 1907, and how banker J.P. Morgan had also offered $25 million to bring the market back to earth:

PANIC ATTACK…banker J.P. Morgan (left) used a pile of money to calm the stock market during the Panic of 1907. His son, J.P. Morgan Jr., (right) would try to do the same following the October 1929 crash, when he and other bankers attempted to prevent a depression by purchasing some overpriced blue chip stock. As we know, their actions had little effect. (Library of Congress)

 *  *  *

Funny Girl

One of Broadway’s biggest stars in the 1920s, Fanny Brice (1891-1951) was profiled by Niven Busch Jr. in the April 20 issue. In addition to her work with the Ziegfeld Follies and other stage productions, by 1929 the comedian, singer and actress had recorded two-dozen songs and appeared in the 1928 film, My Man. Brice’s star would continue to rise in the 1930s and 40s, especially on the radio portraying the bratty toddler “Baby Snooks.” Here are the opening lines of the profile, which included a caricature of Brice by Miguel Covarrubias:

Top right, caricature of Fanny Brice that accompanied the New Yorker profile, drawn by Miguel Covarrubias. Below, publicity photo of Brice as Baby Snooks, 1938. (Photofest)

 *  *  *

From its very beginnings comic verse played an important role in the pages of the New Yorker. The subjects of my previous blog post (Generation of Vipers), sisters Elinor Wylie and Nancy Hoyt, both contributed comic poems to the magazine, as did Clarence Knapp, a former mayor of Saratoga, New York, who also wrote prose pieces on that city’s famed horse racing scene. According to Judith Yaross Lee (Defining New Yorker Humor, p. 354), Knapp was a New Yorker insider who penned a total of 14 mock-melodramatic “sob ballads” between 1927 and 1930. Lee observes that Knapp’s ballads followed a fixed formula, two 16-line stanzas followed by eight-line refrains, that “joked about present social values by invoking past forms.”

*  *  *

They Loved a Parade

After the passing of literary giant Victor Hugo in 1885 (his funeral attracted two million mourners), Paris became known for its spectacular funeral processions. So when famed French general and (WWI) Supreme Allied Commander Marshal Ferdinand Foch died on March 20, 1929, the City of Light turned out in droves to say goodbye. On hand to report the scene was the New Yorker’s Paris correspondent, Janet Flanner, aka Genêt:

A PARIS FAREWELL…The Tricolor-draped coffin of Marshal Ferdinand Foch is escorted by the Allied Commanders from the Great War (WWI) during the funeral procession. The American General John J. Pershing can be seen marching alongside the catafalque in the center of the photo. (Associated Press)

By Flanner’s account, Foch’s send-off easily matched Hugo’s in terms of crowd size:

 *  *  *

The Art of Smoking

Cigarette manufacturers used a variety of marketing techniques to promote their tobacco products. During the late 1920s and early 30s R.J. Reynolds sought to attract more women smokers through a series of stylish ads for its Camel brand that evoked a softly elegant world. These ads were illustrated by Carl Erickson (1891–1958), a fashion artist whose work was widely seen in Vogue and in promotions for Coty cosmetics. This ad appeared in the April 20 issue of the New Yorker:

While studying at Chicago’s Academy of Fine Arts, Erickson was nicknamed “Eric,” a name he later used to sign his works. Also a successful portrait artist, Erickson lived part of his professional life in France (1920 to 1940) with his wife, the fashion illustrator Lee Creelman. Below are several examples of Erickson’s Camel work, including two back page illustrations from Delineator, a women’s fashion magazine that featured Butterick sewing patterns.

Clockwise from top, left, ad from Delineator, July 1930; 1929 ad from unknown source; unknown date and source; Carl “Eric” Erickson at work circa 1950; ad from the Delineator, July 1929. (Delineator/fashionising.com/periodpaper.com)

And From Our Other Advertisers…

With our Cuba relations once again eroding, let’s look back 89 years to a time when affordable, care-free living could be yours in sunny Havana…

…or in the days before foam rubber, “ozonized” animal hair gave bounce to your rugs…

…or the modestly well-off could contemplate an apartment on Park Avenue…

View from a 16th floor condo at 784 Park Avenue, yours today for a cool $8 million. (triumphproperty.com/stribling.com)

Our cartoons come courtesy of Garrett Price (1895-1979), who would contribute hundreds of cartoons as well as 100 covers during his more than 50 years with the New Yorker. An excellent look at Price’s life and work can be found in The Comics Journal…

Garrett Price, circa 1918, and one of his New Yorker covers from May 21, 1949. (The Comics Journal)

…Denys Wortman (1887-1958) looked in on a bookseller with a “spoiler” problem. From 1924 to 1954 Wortman drew the nationally syndicated comic strip Metropolitan Movies for the New York World. The beautifully drawn strip offered a naturalistic portrayal of daily life in New York City…

Denys Wortman at work in an undated photo. At left, an example from his Metropolitan Movies comic strip, dated May 11, 1932. (New York World/New York Times)

…and John Reynolds looked in on the challenges of the architecture profession. Reynolds contributed 34 drawings to the New Yorker from 1928 to 1930.

Next Time: Hello Molly…

 

 

A Fine Mess

Screen Shot 2015-10-27 at 4.32.20 PM
Feb. 27, 1926 cover by H.O. Hofman.

The month of February 1926 must have been miserable in New York City. A massive blizzard made a mess of the streets, which were then topped by a soot-laden smog. The smog was the result of homes and businesses burning soft coal, which produced far more smoke than the hard variety (which was in short supply).

The photo above, from the Daily News archive, shows a chaotic scene on Orchard Street (Manhattan’s Lower East Side) after the storm.

As could be expected, The New Yorker editors tried their best to make light of the situation, although they couldn’t resist making a racist remark regarding the effects of soot on the population. It is also interesting to note that the word “smoggy” was considered by the editors to be a relatively new term:

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 9.51.38 AM

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 9.51.50 AM

Al Frueh showed us how the toffs dealt with the situation…

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 9.52.10 AM

…and Fifth Avenue was not the best place for a fashionable stroll…

nycsnowshoveling
Shovelers were hired to clear the streets after 1926 blizzard (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration)

No doubt the foul weather contributed to the mood of the writers and critics at The New Yorker, who reacted rather sourly to the much ballyhooed Feb. 17, 1926 debut of young Marion Talley at the Metropolitan Opera. At the tender age of 19, she was the youngest prima donna to sing at the Met at that time.

In his “A Reporter at Large” column, Morris Markey scoffed at the hype and small-town boosterism that accompanied the young singer from rural Missouri:

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 10.00.32 AM

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 10.00.47 AM

Talley’s debut performance was as Gilda, the daughter of the title character in Giuseppe Verdi’s Rigoletto. The Metropolitan Opera’s general manager, Giulio Gatti-Casazza, hoped Talley’s debut would be low-key and not overshadow the production. However, a delegation of two hundred leading citizens of Kansas City, including the mayor, arrived via a special train for the event.

Adding to the chaos, a noisy telegraph machine was set up backstage so Talley’s father could send dispatches to the Associated Press.

Marion_Talley_crop
OVER EXPOSED: Marion Talley in 1926. (Library of Congress)

Talley’s swift rise to fame would be followed by a relatively quick return to obscurity. After appearing in seven productions at the Met, her contract was not renewed for the 1929 season.

Next Time: Life of a Rum Runner…

Screen Shot 2015-10-30 at 10.13.15 AM